Skip to main content Skip to main content

Book Direct and Save up to 25%

Only when you Click Here

Key West First Legal Rum Distillery at the Gates Hotel

Key West First Legal Rum Distillery at the Gates Hotel

Key West First Legal Rum Distillery at the Gates Hotel

Rum has a special place in our hearts here in Key West. During Prohibition, this island once played an important role in the rum-running trade as one of the key stops for smuggling Caribbean rum into Florida speakeasies. Today it remains the spirit of choice down here in the Florida Keys, whether it’s muddled with fresh limes and mint for a refreshing mojito or blended with orange and pineapple for a sunny rum runner.

At Gates, we’ve partnered with Paul Menta of Key West First Legal Rum Distillery to feature a private-label selection of his finest spirits at our Rum Row bar. As its name implies, this is the first legal Key West rum distillery on the island, which opened in 2013 in a former Coca-Cola bottling plant.

Paul himself is a unique character—a professional kite boarder, chef, restaurateur, and now rum distiller, he draws inspiration from local ingredients and flavors for his distinctly Key West rum. His “Chef Distilled” philosophy emphasizes a farm-to-bottle approach that sources native Floridian ingredients whenever possible, from the Demerera sugar cane used in distilling to the key limes, oranges, and vanilla beans used in rum infusions. The result is smooth, delicious rum that Paul declares as “hangover free.”

Key West First Legal Rum Distillery at the Gates Hotel
Key West First Legal Rum Distillery at the Gates Hotel

At Rum Row’s pool, bar, and lounge at Gates Hotel

Experience Key West First Legal Rum through a selection of handcrafted cocktails inspired by Key West history, such as “Up in Smoke” (a nod to the cigar industry) featuring First Legal’s raw and unfiltered rum, or the Tomoka Mojito, named after a famous rum-running ship. We’ll also carry a selection of aged and dark sipping rums to enjoy neat or with a simple ice cube—the perfect pairing for a Rodriguez Cigar, if you so choose.

The Gates will frequently host rum tastings and other special cocktail events at Rum Row. Join our mailing list to learn more about events as well as tours to Key West First Legal Rum Distillery, where you can meet Paul himself!


From sunset cruises, glass bottom boat rides, kayaking to the ever popular all-day Ultimate Adventure, there's something for everyone!


One of the most notable design elements of The Gates is a collection of striking imagery by award-winning local photographer and artist Jorge de la Torriente of De La Gallery.

Key West Theater and The Gates Hotel Key West

The Key West Theater is a newly-renovated performing arts center that presents top tier music, concerts, theatrical productions, comedy & variety specials and locally produced Key West events.


Guests of The Gates Key West are sure to enjoy an exhilarating round as well as special rates.

Rodriguez Cigar Lounge in Key West

Key West’s cigar legacy dates back to the mid-19th century, when Cuban refugees began fleeing to the island during their country’s revolution against Spain.

The Gates Concierge will help you Unlock The Keys

Whether you are starting to plan your Key West vacation or have already checked in to The Gates, our Concierge team is ready to help you discover the beauty, charm and excitement of the island.